| Where your data lives | On your phone, encryptedSQLCipher + encrypted vault, on hardware you own | In their cloudtheir database, their jurisdiction, their breach |
| Internet goes down | Nothing happensoffline is the default mode, not a degraded one | Check-ins stop“couldn't connect — try again later” |
| Servers & infrastructure | Noneno server, no UPS, no NAS, no IT contractor | Their SaaS + your ITand an onboarding call to set it up |
| Extra hardware to buy | Noneany old Android phone or tablet becomes the kiosk — NFC needs no cards, fobs or readers | Terminals, readers, badgesdedicated clocks, plus a card or fob per employee — replaced every time one is lost |
| Power cut at the site | Keeps workingphones and kiosk run on batteries | Router's dead — so is ithope you kept paper timesheets |
| Setup | Minutesinstall two apps, pair them with a QR code, add your people | An IT projectsales demo, onboarding sessions, configuration backlog |
| Worker onboarding | Scan one QRno email, no password, no account to create — or to reset | Email invites + passwordsand the eternal “forgot my password” parade |
| Who can read your payroll | Only youend-to-end encrypted; the vendor holds nothing | You, the vendor, their cloud providerand anyone who breaches any of them |
| Subscription | None — you pay once per device€10 per employee, one-time activation key; nothing renews, ever | Monthly fee, per user, forevertypically $2–12 per user per month, plus base fees — see the math below |
| Faking a check-in | Cryptographically hardsigned single-use tokens; NFC challenge-response can't be replayed or photographed | Photo of a colleague's QRor sharing a PIN — classic |
| NFC check-in | Phone-to-phone, cryptographica live challenge-response with the worker's phone — the only attendance app we know of that does this | Typically a tag on a wall, or a badge + readera tag marks a place, not a person — and can be cloned |
| Watching your workers | Presence, not surveillancea check-in proves the worker was at the kiosk, that moment — no all-day GPS, no geofences, no face scans | Often all-day GPS trackinggeofences, breadcrumb trails and face checks — on the worker's personal phone and battery |
| Workers' private chat | End-to-end encryptedonly the coworkers in the conversation can read it — not the boss, not the kiosk, not the relay, not even us; never in the office backup | Stored readable on the vendor's serversprivacy from the employer is at best a vendor policy — in some products the owner can export every worker's private messages |
| Connecting an AI | Your AI, no vendor cloudMCP endpoint on your own phone — works even with a fully local model on your own computer | Vendor-cloud AI, at besttheir servers, their copy of your data — even when they let you plug an AI in |
| Remote site with no coverage | Fully supportedoffline kiosks + courier phone syncs by visiting | Unsupportedno signal, no product |
| When a worker leaves | GDPR auto-scrub, built inset a retention period once — personal data of ex-employees erases itself; payroll history stays, as the law requires | Your problemmanual cleanup across their cloud, exports and backups — if anyone remembers |
| If the vendor disappears | App keeps working — it's all localyour data was never hostage | Service off, data export “on request”good luck with that |